Recurring Deposits (RDs) are a popular choice for individuals who prefer disciplined savings with assured returns. Both Post Office Recurring Deposits (PORD) and Bank RDs serve the purpose of accumulating savings over time, but they differ significantly in terms of features, benefits, and suitability for various financial goals. If you’re looking to understand whether a Post Office RD works the same way as a bank RD, this detailed blog will help you make an informed decision.
What is a Post Office Recurring Deposit (PORD)?
The Post Office Recurring Deposit is a savings scheme backed by the Government of India, designed for individuals looking for risk-free returns. Managed by India Post, this scheme ensures security and predictable growth over a fixed tenure of 5 years.
What is a Bank Recurring Deposit (RD)?
Bank RDs are similar savings products offered by commercial banks. They provide the flexibility to choose tenure and deposit amounts while earning interest at pre-fixed rates. They are managed entirely by banks and are widely accessible.
Key Differences Between Post Office RD and Bank RD
Feature | Post Office RD (PORD) | Bank RD |
Backing Institution | Government of India | Scheduled Commercial Banks |
Tenure | Fixed at 5 years | Flexible tenure options (6 months to 10 years) |
Interest Rate | Revised quarterly by the government (e.g., ~6.5% p.a.) | Fixed at the time of opening; varies by bank |
Loan/Overdraft Facility | Not available | Offered by most banks (up to 90% of RD balance) |
Tax Benefits | Eligible for Section 80C if reinvested in eligible schemes | Generally, no tax benefits (except some 5-year RDs) |
Premature Withdrawal | Allowed after 3 years with penalties | Allowed anytime, but penalties may apply |
Risk Factor | Zero risk, as it is government-backed | Low risk, backed by commercial banks |
Mode of Management | Largely manual; limited online options | Fully digital; managed via mobile apps and net banking |
Deposit Amounts | Minimum ₹100 per month; no upper limit | Minimum ₹100; upper limit varies by bank |
1. Interest Rates: Fixed vs. Revised
Post Office RD:
The interest rate is determined by the government and is revised every quarter. For example, as of now, it is approximately 6.5% p.a.
The rate remains fixed for the entire 5-year tenure once the account is opened.
Bank RD:
Interest rates vary from bank to bank and are determined based on the bank's policies and market conditions.
The rates are locked at the time of opening the account and do not change for that tenure.
2. Flexibility in Tenure
Post Office RD:
Offers a fixed tenure of 5 years, making it ideal for medium-term savings goals.
No flexibility to choose a shorter or longer tenure.
Bank RD:
Provides flexible tenures ranging from 6 months to 10 years.
Suitable for both short-term and long-term financial goals.
3. Accessibility and Convenience
Post Office RD:
Requires physical visits to the post office for account opening, monthly deposits, and withdrawals.
Limited online services available only to account holders with India Post’s internet banking.
Bank RD:
Fully accessible through online platforms like mobile apps and internet banking.
Auto-debit options ensure timely monthly payments without manual intervention.
4. Loan and Overdraft Facilities
Post Office RD:
Does not offer loans or overdrafts against RD balances. If you need funds, you must withdraw prematurely, which incurs penalties.
Bank RD:
Most banks provide loans or overdraft facilities against RD balances, allowing you to borrow up to 90% of your RD amount.
This is useful for meeting emergency financial needs without breaking the RD.
5. Taxation and Benefits
Post Office RD:
Interest earned is fully taxable under "Income from Other Sources."
Post Office RDs do not offer direct Section 80C benefits. However, if the maturity amount is reinvested into eligible schemes like PPF or NSC, it can qualify for tax savings.
Bank RD:
Similar taxation rules apply, with interest treated as taxable income.
A 5-year tax-saving RD from some banks may qualify for Section 80C benefits.
6. Premature Withdrawal
Post Office RD:
Withdrawals are permitted after 3 years but incur penalties.
The remaining deposits can continue to earn interest until maturity.
Bank RD:
Banks allow premature withdrawals at any time but charge penalties, which vary by institution.
The penalty may also include a reduction in applicable interest rates.
7. Risk Factor
Post Office RD:
Backed by the Government of India, it is a zero-risk investment option.
Bank RD:
While commercial banks are reliable, they do carry slightly more risk compared to government-backed schemes.
Deposits are insured up to ₹5 lakh under the Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC).
8. Who Should Choose What?
Choose Post Office RD If:
You are risk-averse and want a government-backed savings scheme.
You prefer guaranteed returns for a fixed tenure of 5 years.
You’re saving for a medium-term goal and don’t require loans or overdrafts.
Choose Bank RD If:
You need flexibility in tenure and deposit amounts.
You prefer managing your RD digitally with ease of online access.
You may need a loan or overdraft against your RD in the future.
9. Maximizing Returns and Benefits
For Post Office RD: Consider reinvesting the maturity proceeds into other government-backed schemes like PPF or NSC for tax benefits and compounded growth.
For Bank RD: Compare interest rates across banks and opt for one offering the highest rates for your desired tenure.
Conclusion
While Post Office RDs and Bank RDs are similar in offering fixed returns and disciplined savings, they differ in terms of flexibility, accessibility, and additional features. If security and a medium-term goal are your priorities, a Post Office RD is a great choice. However, if you value flexibility, convenience, and liquidity, a Bank RD is better suited to your needs.
Evaluate your financial goals and choose the RD that aligns with your preferences and requirements. Both options offer a reliable path toward achieving your savings objectives!
Comments