For investors seeking a reliable source of passive income, monthly income schemes offer an enticing opportunity. Whether you have a substantial sum of idle funds or are exploring avenues to generate a consistent cash flow, these schemes cater to your financial aspirations. While traditional investment vehicles like mutual funds might not inherently provide monthly payouts, fear not – India's financial landscape offers specialised mutual fund options designed to deliver regular monthly income distributions. In this article, we compare two important monthly income schemes, Post Office Monthly Income Scheme (POMIS), and their contemporary mutual fund counterparts, equipping you with the knowledge to make an informed decision that aligns with your financial goals.
What are post office Schemes?
Post Office schemes are small savings instruments offered by the Indian Postal Department. These schemes are backed by the Government of India and are considered safe investment options for risk-averse investors. Some popular Post Office schemes include the Post Office Savings Account, Recurring Deposit, Time Deposit, and the Monthly Income Scheme (POMIS).
What is a Post Office Monthy Income Scheme (POMIS)?
POMIS is a government-backed scheme offered by India Post. It functions like a fixed deposit, where you invest a lump sum for a fixed tenure (5 years). The scheme offers a guaranteed monthly interest payout. The primary objective of a POMIS is to preserve investor capital.
How does a POMIS work?
You invest a lump sum amount at your local post office. The minimum investment can be as low as ₹1,000 and you can invest in multiples of that amount. There's a maximum investment limit of ₹9 lakh for a single account and ₹15 lakh for a joint account (as of April 2024).
The current tenure for POMIS is 5 years. You cannot extend the scheme after maturity, but you can reinvest the matured amount.
Returns and Payouts
POMIS offers a fixed interest rate set quarterly by the Government of India, which is 7.40% per annum as of April - June 2024. This rate is guaranteed and applies throughout the entire 5-year tenure.
The monthly interest is calculated via the formula:
POMIS Monthly Interest = (Total Amount Invested * Annual Interest Rate)/12
For example, if you were to invest Rs. 9,00,000 in a POMIS during April-June 2024 for a tenure of 5 years, you will receive a monthly interest of
POMIS Monthly Interest = (9,00,000 * 0.074)/12 = Rs. 5,550
Upon reaching maturity, you have the option to withdraw the principal investment of Rs. 9,00,000, along with the accrued interest, either by collecting it from any post office branch or by requesting a direct transfer to their savings account.
In addition, you can also re-invest the amount received into another POMIS scheme.
Early Withdrawal
If you were to prematurely withdraw your POMIS before completing one year, you wont receive any benefits and will be charged a penalty based on the time of redemption. If you withdraw between the 1st and 3rd year, the entire deposit will be refunded after deducting a 2% penalty. If you withdraw between the 3rd and 5th year, the entire deposit will be refunded with a 1% penalty.
Key Features of POMIS
Sovereign guarantee: POMIS is backed by the Government of India, ensuring the safety of your investment.
Low Risk: Government backing ensures the safety of your principal investment. POMIS is a low-risk investment with guaranteed returns.
Interest rate: The interest rate is fixed and determined by the government, offering stability but potentially lower returns compared to other market-linked investments.
Monthly Income: POMIS offers a steady flow of income through monthly payouts, making it suitable for those seeking regular income.
Liquidity: Premature withdrawal is allowed, but with penalty charges.
Taxation: Interest earned from POMIS is taxable as per your income tax slab.
Low Returns: The returns may not keep pace with inflation over extended periods.
Who should invest in POMIS?
The Post Office Monthly Income Scheme (POMIS) is an attractive option for risk-averse investors seeking a stable monthly income stream. Retirees, pensioners, or individuals with a low-risk tolerance who prioritize capital preservation and a guaranteed income may find POMIS a suitable investment choice.
What is a Mutual Fund?
A Mutual Fund pools money from multiple investors and invests it in a basket of assets like stocks, bonds, and other securities. A professional fund manager oversees these investments, aiming to generate returns for investors.
There are various types of Mutual Funds catering to different risk profiles. Equity Funds invest primarily in stocks and offer the potential for high returns, but also carry higher risk due to market fluctuations. Debt Funds invest in fixed-income securities like bonds and offer lower risk with predictable, though often lower, returns. Hybrid Funds offer a mix of equity and debt, balancing risk and potential returns.
Additionally, mutual funds provide the option of Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs), which allow investors to invest a fixed amount at regular intervals, such as monthly or quarterly. SIPs help inculcate the discipline of regular investing and benefit from rupee cost averaging, wherein an investor can potentially lower the average cost of their investment by accumulating more units when the prices are low and fewer units when the prices are high.
Key Features of Mutual Funds
Diversification: Mutual Funds spread your investment across various assets, mitigating risk from any single asset underperforming.
Professional Management: Fund managers with expertise handle investment decisions, freeing you from actively monitoring the market.
Variety of Options: Choose a Mutual Fund that aligns with your risk appetite and investment goals.
Potential for High Returns: Equity Funds, particularly over the long term, have historically offered higher returns compared to fixed-income options.
Liquidity: Depending on the type of Mutual Fund, you may be able to redeem your investment quickly (open-ended funds) or face a lock-in period (closed-ended funds).
Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs): Mutual funds offer the flexibility of SIPs, which enable investors to invest small amounts periodically, making it easier to start investing with limited capital.
Who Should Invest in Mutual Funds?
Mutual funds are well-suited for investors with a moderately high-risk appetite and a longer investment horizon. If you're seeking the potential for capital appreciation and are willing to navigate market fluctuations, mutual funds could be an ideal choice. Additionally, investors looking to diversify their portfolio and benefit from professional management may find mutual funds appealing.
Table of Differences: Mutual Fund vs. Post Office Monthly Income Scheme
Feature | Mutual Funds | POMIS |
Investment Type | Basket of assets (stocks, bonds etc.) | Fixed income |
Risk Profile | Moderate to high | Low |
Potential Returns | Higher (subject to market performance) | Fixed and lower |
Liquidity | Generally high | Limited liquidity, penalty for premature withdrawal |
Taxation | Capital gains and dividends are taxed. | Taxable as per your income tax slab. |
Investment Management | Professional fund managers | Government-managed |
Investment Horizon | Depends on the scheme, ELSS has a 3 year lockin period | Fixed at 5 Years |
Diversification | Diversified portfolio | Single investment |
Alternative Mutual Fund Monthly Income Schemes
While POMIS offers a guaranteed income stream, some Mutual Funds cater to investors seeking a similar benefit. Monthly Income Plans (MIPs) are debt-oriented Mutual Funds that aim to distribute a portion of their earnings to investors regularly, typically monthly. MIPs from mutual fund schemes invest a small part of the corpus (5-25%) in equities with a goal to beat other debt instruments like POMIS. However, unlike POMIS, these payouts are not guaranteed and can fluctuate based on the fund's performance.
Table of Differences between MF Monthly Income Plans (MIPs) and POMIS
Feature | MF Monthly Income Plans | POMIS |
Investment Type | Debt Oriented Mutual Funds | Fixed income |
Risk Profile | Lower risk compared to equity funds, but higher than POMIS | Low |
Returns | Higher, but not guaranteed, depends on fund performance | Lower, but guaranteed by the government |
Income Source | Dividends and capital appreciation | Fixed interest payments |
Liquidity | Generally high | Limited liquidity before maturity |
Investment Management | Professional fund managers | Government-managed |
Diversification | Diversified portfolio | Single investment |
Conclusion
The choice between Mutual Funds and POMIS hinges on your individual circumstances and financial goals. Here's a quick recap to aid your decision:
Seeking High Returns with Moderate to High Risk Tolerance? Ask your investment counselor's opinion on Mutual Funds. They offer the potential for significant wealth creation over the long term, but be prepared for market fluctuations.
Prioritising Guaranteed Income and Capital Protection? Ask your investment counselor's opinion on POMIS. It provides a predictable monthly income stream and low risk, but the returns may not keep pace with inflation over time.
Remember, both investment avenues have their unique advantages and drawbacks. It's essential to carefully consider your personal circumstances, investment horizon, and risk profile before making a decision. Consult with your investment counsellor to navigate the intricacies of these investment options and craft a well-diversified portfolio that aligns with your long-term financial aspirations.
留言