Both NPS (National Pension System) and POMIS (Post Office Monthly Income Scheme) are popular investment options in India, but they serve different financial goals. NPS is focused on retirement savings, while POMIS is designed to provide regular monthly income. Below is a detailed comparison between NPS and POMIS to help you choose the right investment option based on your needs.
1. Purpose and Objective
NPS (National Pension System):
Objective: NPS is a long-term, retirement-focused savings scheme. The primary goal is to help individuals accumulate a corpus for their retirement and convert it into a monthly pension post-retirement.
Retirement Planning: NPS aims to provide a pension income after retirement, ensuring financial security during the post-retirement phase.
POMIS (Post Office Monthly Income Scheme):
Objective: POMIS is a fixed-income investment scheme aimed at providing monthly income to individuals, especially senior citizens or those looking for a stable income stream.
Income Generation: POMIS is ideal for investors who want a regular monthly income and can also be used as a part of short-to-medium-term financial planning.
2. Investor Type
NPS:
Target Audience: NPS is primarily aimed at individuals planning for retirement. It is suitable for salaried employees (especially those in the government sector) as well as self-employed individuals looking for long-term retirement savings.
It is open to both government employees (mandatory for new recruits) and private sector employees (voluntary).
POMIS:
Target Audience: POMIS is popular among individuals seeking a regular monthly income. It is especially beneficial for retirees, senior citizens, and those who want to park their savings in a low-risk, income-generating instrument.
It's a suitable option for individuals who want to ensure financial security in their later years through predictable, fixed monthly income.
3. Investment Structure
NPS:
Contributory: NPS is a defined contribution scheme where both the employee and employer contribute towards the fund. It allows you to invest in various asset classes like equity, corporate bonds, and government securities.
Market-Linked: The returns on NPS are market-linked, depending on the performance of the underlying assets. The investment grows based on the contributions and the returns from market investments.
Exit Strategy: At retirement, you are required to use at least 40% of the corpus to purchase an annuity that provides a monthly pension. You can withdraw the remaining 60% of the corpus as a lump sum (tax-free).
POMIS:
Fixed Deposit Scheme: POMIS is a fixed-income scheme offered by India Post. The interest rate on POMIS is fixed for a period of 5 years.
Income-Generating: POMIS provides a guaranteed monthly interest payment based on the principal amount you invest. The scheme does not offer market-linked returns and is ideal for those seeking stable, predictable income.
Exit Strategy: The tenure of POMIS is 5 years, and the interest is paid monthly. The principal can be withdrawn after the maturity period or after paying a penalty for premature withdrawal.
4. Investment Limit and Duration
NPS:
Minimum Contribution: The minimum contribution for NPS is ₹500 per month or ₹6,000 annually.
Maximum Contribution: There is no maximum contribution limit to NPS. You can contribute as much as you want, and the more you contribute, the larger your corpus will be at the time of retirement.
Tenure: NPS is a long-term investment (usually until the age of 60) and is meant for retirement.
POMIS:
Minimum Investment: The minimum investment in POMIS is ₹1,500 for an individual or a joint account.
Maximum Investment: The maximum investment is ₹4.5 lakh for an individual and ₹9 lakh for a joint account.
Tenure: The tenure of POMIS is 5 years, and you receive monthly interest payments. The scheme can be extended after maturity.
5. Returns
NPS:
Market-Linked Returns: NPS offers market-linked returns, which means the returns depend on the performance of the chosen asset class (equity, government bonds, or corporate bonds). Historically, NPS returns range between 8% to 10% per annum, but they can vary depending on the market conditions.
Volatility: The returns in NPS are subject to market risks, especially if a significant portion of the corpus is invested in equity markets.
POMIS:
Fixed Interest Rate: POMIS offers a fixed interest rate, which is not linked to market performance. As of now, the interest rate is around 7.4% per annum, which is paid out monthly.
Interest Payment: The interest is paid monthly, making it a good option for those who need a steady income. The principal invested in POMIS does not fluctuate with market conditions.
6. Liquidity
NPS:
Low Liquidity: NPS has a lock-in period until retirement (usually age 60). Early withdrawals are allowed only under specific conditions (such as 25% of your own contribution after 3 years), and even then, there are restrictions on how much can be withdrawn.
Partial Withdrawals: You can make partial withdrawals for specific purposes like higher education, marriage, or medical emergencies after 3 years.
POMIS:
Moderate Liquidity: POMIS is more liquid compared to NPS. You can withdraw your principal at the end of the 5-year term, and if you need to withdraw earlier, you can do so by paying a penalty. However, early withdrawals may result in a reduced interest payout.
Interest Payouts: Monthly interest payouts provide liquidity in terms of regular income. However, the principal remains invested for the full 5-year term unless prematurely withdrawn.
7. Tax Benefits
NPS:
Tax Deduction: NPS offers tax benefits under Section 80C (up to ₹1.5 lakh) and Section 80CCD(1B) (additional ₹50,000), which is over and above the ₹1.5 lakh limit of Section 80C.
Tax on Returns: The returns generated by NPS are tax-deferred. The lump sum withdrawal of 60% at retirement is tax-free. However, the annuity (40% of the corpus) is taxable as regular income.
Tax-Free Growth: NPS allows tax-free growth on your contributions until you reach retirement.
POMIS:
Tax Treatment: The interest income from POMIS is taxable under the head “Income from Other Sources.” The principal amount invested in POMIS is not tax-deductible, so you do not receive tax deductions on the initial investment.
TDS on Interest: If the interest earned exceeds ₹40,000 in a financial year (₹50,000 for senior citizens), TDS (Tax Deducted at Source) is applicable.
8. Risk and Safety
NPS:
Market Risks: Since NPS has a market-linked component, the risk depends on the type of asset allocation chosen by the investor. There is a potential for higher returns, but the value of the investment can fluctuate depending on the market performance.
Government Backed: Despite being market-linked, NPS is regulated by the Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA), making it a relatively secure investment option.
POMIS:
Low Risk: POMIS is a low-risk investment as it is backed by the Indian government. The interest is guaranteed and is not subject to market fluctuations.
Fixed Returns: Since POMIS offers fixed returns, it is ideal for conservative investors looking for a safe, steady income source.
9. Suitability
NPS:
Ideal for: Individuals looking for a long-term retirement savings plan with tax benefits and market-linked returns. It is suitable for those who want to build a pension corpus and are willing to take some market risks.
Best for: Retirement planning and long-term investors who do not require immediate regular income but are focused on creating wealth over time.
POMIS:
Ideal for: People looking for a low-risk investment that offers a steady, guaranteed monthly income. It’s especially beneficial for senior citizens, retirees, or those who need consistent cash flow.
Best for: Those who want to park their money in a safe instrument and receive regular income without taking on
Comments